BRUCEGOURLEY.COM

  John Leland: Evolving Views of Slavery, 1789-1839
 As published in the Baptist History and Heritage Journal

HOME

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Leland Essay Main Page   /    More Writings by Bruce Gourley 

 

(Part 5 of 7)
THE ANTI-ABOLITIONIST LELAND: 1839

Leland's pen was mostly silent during the years 1837 and 1838, although he did address some religious matters. In 1837, following several years of federal budget surpluses, Wall Street crashed. A great depression swept the country and lasted until 1843. (43) Against this backdrop, Leland addressed the issue of slavery one final time. In a speech delivered on August 16, 1839, he spoke of two things: the need for an independent treasury and slavery. The speech remarkably represented a complete about-face from his petition to Virginia Baptists in 1789. In addition to dismissing the increasingly vocal calls for emancipation of slaves, the aging preacher-politician downplayed the plight of slaves and offered kind words to slave owners. Furthermore, Leland insisted that the federal government had no responsibility, nor should take any action, in regards to slavery. Instead, the fate of slavery should properly be determined by slaveholders:

   The slave-holders are to be addressed: the power lies in them

   alone. It is not an article to be settled by legislation among us.

   It belongs to the moral and religious department, and not to the

   legislative. Three parties are concerned in the question, viz:

   God--the master-and the slave. As a friend to freedom and right,

   I earnestly recommend to masters to set their slaves at liberty as

   soon as their good, their choice, and the public safety concur.

   Until then, be good to them, remembering you have a Master in

   heaven, whose orders are, 'Whatsover you would that men should

   do unto you, do you even the same unto them.' Make their lives as

   happy as circumstances will admit of. If there is a condition for

   them to be in, better than their present state (where their masters

   are humane, just, and benevolent), I pray the Lord, and call upon

   men, to bestow it upon them. With all deference to the opinions of

   others, I would recommend to the abolition orators to serve an

   apprenticeship of seven years in a slave--holding state to qualify

   their minds to view the question in all its bearings. (44)

This position of government non-interference represented a complete reversal of Leland's previous stance of government intervention, a stance he maintained up to a mere three years earlier. The statement also reflected his altered view of slave owners, who went from being brutal to being "humane, just, and benevolent." With this final statement on slavery, nearly fifty years of antislavery sentiment were seemingly negated, even as Leland insisted that he remained a "friend to freedom and right."

Continue to Conclusion